I've never been to New York, so I don't have anything to compare it to. But honestly, I've had plenty of other hot dogs and these ones taste just like those. LOL! I think what makes it special is that it's located on crazy Fremont Street & I don't know about others, but I always feel just a little bit like doing something out of my comfort zone when I walk around here. Like for me, getting hot dogs from a restaurant when they're easy & way cheaper to make at home is completely unlike me. But why be sensible??!!! You're in Downtown LV, people!!! So, go for it!! And while you're at it, slap some chili on those hot dogs!!!! My guys pushed it to the max...they cheesed up theirs!!! Woot!! We are edgy!!!! :-D LOL!!!!