My wife and I had an outstanding experience at Tavern on 91! Food and service were both fantastic! It has enough to satisfy every "in the box" eater, but also has some great "outside of the box" selections.
Our drinks came out promptly and tasted great. We ordered the Rib appetizer as well as the shrimp appetizer and both were outstanding.
For our entrees, my wife got the Cobb Salad and I got the Mahi Mahi sandwich. Both were outstanding! The Mahi sandwich was one of the best I have ever eaten in the Cleveland area and at only 11 bucks I would say it was one of the best-valued Mahi sandwiches I have ever eaten as well. My wife really liked that the menu specified what items were gluten free, which I might add is a pretty expansive GF selection.
The new owners really gave the space a better feel than it had when it was Panini's. And while I'm not exactly sure what they did other than clean it up, take down the tacky beer signs, and place a giant smoker in the middle, the place seems to have a much cozier vibe than it used to when it was Panini's.