Seeing that I'm not a fan of Italian food [I know, crazy]--this place was A+.
The place was empty and the atmosphere was a little bleak but the waiter was attentive and the food was excellent.
I ordered an 'off-menu' item: risotto with porcinis and truffles: perfect, perfect.
My lovely date had something similar to pasta carbonara, except it wasn't as cream heavy.
The wine list was bank...most wines were well over $60-70.
Overall, a good meal and I'd probably come back if I was in Montreal--and needing an Italian fix.