I'd give it 3 1/2 stars. Reason why it's always packed is because they only bake 12 at a time. The first time I tasted the cake, it was very bland, however, it really grows on you and you'll start to really taste the subtle flavors (it actually tastes like cheese). Plus it doesn't feel too heavy unlike a traditional cheesecake, but that doesn't mean it's healthy. Pretty sure a lot of butter and eggs go into making this. Overall I like the place, and I guess I didn't mind waiting almost 2 hours outside at night. Not so much into the muffins. Can't wait for the new desserts.