I would have given it a 2.5, as it was better than "Meh - I've expereinced better" and less than "A-OK". Don't get me wrong, the desserts are out of this world. However, I see why it's called "Tony's Ice Cream". I wouldn't recommend going for burgers, as they seem to have the equivalent of "trucker food". Not very tasty, greasy, and unappealing. The desserts are insane, nonetheless. Definitely my stop for milkshakes, cakes, and ice cream pints...but that's it.