We came here the first time we were in Montreal a couple years ago and really liked it but we didn't really order food then...just beer and shared a basic flatbread.
So we came back and the beer was still great but the food was not. Server was nice enough but we got sat right in front of the door with cold air blasting us every minute or so. It had seemed like the restaurant was really crowded when they sat us there but it turns out it wasn't and they just sat us there to torture us maybe?
If the beer wasn't so great, it would definitely have been a one star.