We ran into this place while trying to get back to our hotel but finding refuge from the cold. We were glad we did! Scott Nicholson and David something were playing and they were awesome! We had never been to a dueling piano bar before and the experience was awesome since the players were engaged in witty banter and freestyle lyrics at times. They played everything from Guns N Roses, Billy Joel, Frank Sinatra, Janis Joplin, Journey, BOHEMIAN RHAPSODY (!) and others. We heard the classics, typical karaoke songs, motown, country, and basically all-American songs that cater to the people from the Midwest. I think we were the only minorities (Asians) here for most of the night.
I would definitely come back! Drinks are about $10 each. Most of the piano requests were $20-$40. Some even threw in $100. Crazy.