I'm not from Cleveland so I'm not sure how many places serve cocktails like this in town, but I assume it's the only one based on prices and service. Otherwise people would go elsewhere.
Drinks- we tried 3 and all were very good. However, $15 is steep - even in more expensive places like chicago & Seattle. I have no problem paying $15 for a drink- but I expect good service and atmosphere to go with it.
Atmosphere - decor and space is nice, nothing super interesting but it's nice. However since there appeared to be only one set of speakers the dj was BLASTING the music at an uncomfortable level. We had to repeatedly yell things to have a conversation while being a foot apart.
Service. Was. Terrible. So so bad. I stood at the bar for over 10 minutes (no exaggeration) without being even acknowledged. There were 5 people behind the bar and what appeared to be a manger walking throughout the place and it was not crazy busy- steady yes, but not busy. Plenty of space to just walk up the bar and order if someone would bother talking to you. During my time waiting I did get to see the bartenders mess up drinks multiple times and toss them, break glasses, and fight with each other- loudly and obviously. Super professional.
I'd go back if you're craving a really good cocktail and can't find literally anywhere else.