Colangelo's is great. I stopped in for a focaccia and it was amazing. It was nice and fluffy. I got one with artichokes on top.
They also have Sicilian (square) pizza which seemed really popular as well as some pasta and baked good options. Everyone was getting pizza or focaccia when I was there.
The place is a take-away, though they have a few high top tables inside and some tables outside.