I've been a few times now, and I feel like it's time to review.
Good things first:
1) Great beer list
2) Weeknight specials are steals
3) Bacon blue cheese fries
4) Pretty solid commitment to using local products
The not so good:
1) Most tap beers are $6
2) Service ranges from frantic, overbearing, adderall'd frat boy to absent. (read: I've never had good service here)
3) It gets LOUD
For the most part, Tipsy Cow does an OK job but the service needs some improvement. All the taps are usually great selections, but $6 is kiiiiiiiiind of ridiculous. They have a tap of the day (or week or month or something) that's usually $3.50, but it tends to be the least desirable on the list. The food is nothing to rave about, but it's a step above similar places. I'll definitely be back - I'm a sucker for 1/2 price wings and fries - but Tipsy Cow still needs a lil' tweaking.