5 stars for macarons - very good selection of flavor, delicate and consistent structure, plus balanced flavor
4 stars for desserts - consistently good quality without any Wow's in my opinion. Very limited and common selection in a daily basis.
3 stars for price - I am glad that there comes a fine quality pâtisserie in Pittsburgh, but sorry to say, with their selection and quality of cakes, they are over priced. I believe David could do better tho. PGH needs more inspiring personal sized cakes, please!