I'm a bit on the fence here. I don't think they are quite 5 stars, but better than 4 stars. 4.5 stars would be my actual rating.
First time here, came for lunch on a Tuesday. I thought it was just a bar with possibly a small dining room. I was not expecting this place to be such a swanky joint.
The lunch menu is outstanding!! The garlic bread they bring out is good. Our server brought out 3 ramekin's of marinara sauce, once for each of us. That was super thoughtful, because double dipping is necessary!! We ordered a chicken parm sandwhich, spaghetti and meatball, and lasagna.
My buddy said the chicken parm is his second favorite in town. That says a lot since he ALWAYS orders a chicken parm sandwhich at every sandwich shop we go to!! My other buddy got the lunch spaghetti and meatball. It came with a house salad that was pretty substantial in its own right. He said he was kind of full from just the salad and bread, but he toughed it out and ate his spaghetti. He said it was really good, and overall a great value. I had the lasagna and it was really good. I would say it is one of the better lasagna's I've eaten.
Overall I was very impressed with the entire place. Our server was super friendly and helpful when ordering. He provided excellent service, I only wish I caught his name. Will definitely be back.