Went for our anniversary and it was perfect. They always make you feel important even as you look around and see everyone from rock stars to people like us. The place is perfect for a romantic dinner or a celebratory meal. I had the Peppered Steak and my wife had the Pan Roasted Chicken. Her salad was exactly how she enjoys it, and the deserts were delicious.
I appreciate that the impressive wine list isn't overpriced at all but quite reasonable compared to other places of this caliber. I can assure you we will be back to Tarbell's for another special occasion soon. (we might just have to create one, so we can go again sooner rather than later)