I like McBroom's for their selection but the prices are higher than I am used to paying for beer that can be found at most other distributos. The stuff you can't find anywhere else in Pittsburgh makes sense to have a price hike but the few times I've tried to get cheap/party beer it is always 2-4 dollars more per case than anywhere else.
I am pretty sure they are owned by the same people as D's Six Pax so I find it funny that a lot of other reviews claim to find it "sweet" that the D's servers sent them here for cases.
McBroom's selection is worth the prices, but the staff usually give the bare minimum of help and sometimes don't acknowledge that they have customers in the store. If you are in the area or looking for something special they are great, but I wouldn't go out of my way for this place on a regular basis.