Don't let the location and the beat-up sign fool you, this place is quite nice on the inside. We arrived on Friday at 7 with a reservation which was clearly not needed. We sat in the back for dinner but it was empty despite being busy up front.
The service from the waiter was excellent from start to finish, formal in a way that was unexpected but not cold. It was a perfect balance and much appreciated.
As for the food, I wouldn't usually order things like mac 'n cheese or perogies but based on his recommendation I did and they were excellent. The crab cakes were excellent, although ginger isn't something I'd usually put on them it was nice for something different, but I liked them plenty with just the sauce.
Price was very reasonable and alcohol wasn't marked up as much as you might think. A thoroughly good dinner. I would return.