Actually 2.5 stars.
The parking for this location is a bit of a pain, but luckily we managed to get one of the last few spots available on the street. From there it was a few minutes walk to get to the restaurant area.
Walking around, it was very clean and felt very different from anywhere else we experienced in toronto. The lighting was good, it was lively, and you could see the CN Tower in the distance.
Once we found the Mill Street Brew Pub, we decided to go inside and give it a shot. I got the stargazers beer - which wasn't bad at all. They had lots of options for beer so it was hard to decide. We also tried the jerk chicken quesadilla, which I didn't like at all. It was also fairly pricey for the quantity of food. If I ever go back, I will get someone else on the menu for sure.
Overall, this particular restaurant was average at best, but the area that it was in was absolutely beautiful. We will be back.