I was hoping for decent, New York style pizza. I should have known that with the exception of the New York Deli News in Denver, you should never trust a place with "New York" in its named to actually have New York style food (how many times did I just type New York?).
The sodas? Great, served in giant chilled glasses. The menu? Looked promising (although I was heart broken they didn't have an eggplant parm sandwich). The salad? Mediocre -- bring on the slices!
Sigh. Not even close. Not even good. On par with Papa John's I'd say. I mean, wow. It was CHEWY. Pizza is supposed to be crisp with sauce and cheese, NOT chewy, by any means.
Our server was nice. The place was cute. Perhaps we'd go back in a pinch and try the eggplant rollatini...but never again shall I eat the pizza. Oy.