As a UW student I'm really proud of our Babcock ice cream however personally I would rank the chocolate shoppe as the best ice cream in town. Also they offer ice creams made for special nutrition needs including a variety of soy ice cream, which is really nice for ones with lactose intolerance.
If you prefer creamy flavors I would recommend green tea, as it is not overly sweet so that you can taste the milk thoroughly. Well, I'm not saying that it's a low calorie choice - as the prints on their dishes say, 'you want nutrition, eat carrots.' It's not the time to consider you daily carb and fat intake buddy, it's the time to experience the best of America's dairy land.