Being completely honest, I was not excited to eat here when I found out a friend made a reservation but I was pleasantly surprised. When I looked at the menu beforehand, I was so confused by how authentic it was and wasn't sure what to order -- especially as a picky eater. I really did enjoy the dinner though!
Atmosphere wise, it's a cool place with some unique decorations. I feel like you could dress casual or formal and have many different dinners here. We went for a bachelorette dinner. We had a group of 11 and had fabulous service.
After struggling on what to order, I ended up getting the gnocchi alla simi and I loved it. Originally I thought the portion seemed really small (coming from an American where plates are supposed to be bigger than our heads!) but it turned out to be a great size. I finished the whole thing happily. The meal also included a free bread appetizer. It was decent enough bread but nothing special. I also split a bottle of wine with a friend (the Rosato) and it was delicious.
All in all, it was a good restaurant and even the pickiest waters should be able to find something. You just may have to step out of your comfort zone!