I have mixed feelings about this place. On the one hand, the location is incredible, especially if you can get a seat near the window. It doesn't matter what season it is, there's something really special about sitting inside looking out at the Cathedral.
On the other hand... the foot is sometimes good and sometimes bad. The "Porch" sandwich is great, but I've had the pizza and felt sick afterwards both times (this doesn't happen with other pizza, just FYI). Some of the other more expensive entrees I don't think are worth it- there are a million other restaurants that give you better tasting food. The Porch's cheap, underlying origins really show with these "nicer" entrees.
The beer selection is alright, but for what they're charging they should have a better selection of craft brews. The other liquor is alright, but not great
I'm amazed they charge for what is essentially stale bread with some butter. Kind of odd since that should be included by default.
I never object to going here with a friend, but it usually isn't my first choice either.