Yikes, this location has really bad reviews. I guess I have gotten lucky the more than dozen times I've ordered from here? My experiences have always been good.
I have an account online so I order that way. Even during peak times it has never taken more than 45-60 minutes to have my order at my door. At my most recent delivery the delivery driver reviewed our order at the door and everything was correct, including all of the extra garlic sauces I ordered. I've also ordered takeout (usually before checking out at Smith's in the same parking lot) and it's usually ready in 10-15 minutes. The best part is that I can usually Google "Papa John's promo code" and find an offer for 25%-50% off my order.
Some of our local pizza places are awesome, but I really do enjoy a pepperoni pizza from here. Especially with the garlic sauce for dipping. I tried the new Pepperoni Rolls and thought those were a tasty side as well.