Stopped in here because I was early for an appointment down the street and I had driven by a bunch of times. I am always happy to see a bunch of locally owned shops within in this mostly strip mall esque area. I am super picky when it comes to cupcakes and Maddy's Fatty's did not disappoint! I was also happy to see they were selling Hamantash because you don't really see those at bakeries down south. It was tasty it did seem a touch under-baked to me. I went later in the day so they didn't have a crazy amount of cupcakes left but they had a great flavor assortment.
As far as cupcakes go I think the cinnamon crumb cake was my favorite. There was a big piece of delicious crumb cake on top, with a not to sweet vanilla cinnamon frosting, and then a moist white cake. I thought the cake to frosting ratio was great on all the cupcakes. You weren't overwhelmed with too much frosting. I had a chocolate cupcake with caramel and peanut butter. I didn't really taste the peanut butter until the end but the caramel was awesome. The traditional birthday cake type ones were super tasty as well.
I will definitely be back if in the area again!!!