This place is exceptional, from the decor to the food it is definitely an experience. I must say that I was extremely loyal to Mastro's City Hall before I started coming to Steak 44. This place is basically the same in terms of quality of food and service, the difference is the ambiance. At Mastro's you feel like you're in a stuffy old money ultra high-end steakhouse. Steak 44 is fun, vibrant and lighted! Lol.
My favorite is the Wagyu NY, I've also gotten the Kansas City and the Tomahawk. Their sides are insane, I recommend them all. The appetizers are also absolutely nuts too!
One thing you have to get is the beignet tree. These beignets may be the best beignets you can get outside of New Orleans. They're a great compliment to a heavy meal. Steak 44 fits Arcadia perfectly and it's also a great experience when I go.