Bumping this up to a 4 for now based on the incredible smoked salmon sandwich I just finished polishing off. Ordered it based on Blair's ROTD from a few days ago praising it and wow, I was not disappointed. A heap of smoked salmon on the incredible Ciabatta bread with some veggies and a nice aioli. I was a little disappointed when I opened it up my container and saw the sandwich hadn't been cut in half (I never requested it this way though, so it wasn't their fault). I took out the little plastic knife from the plasticware they gave me, and it cut through the middle of the sandwich, bread and salmon all like it was butter. One of the better sandwiches I've had in my lifetime.
Only thing keeping it from a 5 is I still haven't found a side I'm completely in love with. Last time the roasted potatoes and this time the Red Potato salad. I thought they were both okay, but neither has blown me away. I'll keep trying until I find "the one". I'm sure it's out there somewhere. I'm cutting and pasting those last two sentences for my match.com profile.
Grille is movin on up! I expect it to be at 5 stars for me by year's end.