Ordered from Glass NIckel and it was "good" pizza. Although we had some problems with the online ordering sending out order to a different location then we wanted and then not letting us order again that was taken care of by a good ol phone call. BONUS: they let us use the online ordering coupon over the phone.
The pizza was better than most places in Madison with delicious toppings (lots of them and tasty) but still not on par with the down home mom & pop pizza parlors I have been to. But Glass Nickel, for what it is, did not let me down.
SIDE NOTE: My wife LOVED the pizza.