On a hot night a couple weeks ago the hubs and I decided that ice cream sounded like a great way to cool off and so we decided to give Mary Coyle's a try.
The service was good - our waitress was super friendly and attentive. The ice cream however, left a lot to be desired. Now, I don't need crazy organic, natural, churned by hand, hipster ice cream that comes in all sorts of artsy flavors. I'm perfectly happy with regular old ice cream (we got chocolate and mint chocolate chip). But I'm not into super sugary, artificially colored and flavored, modified dairy product. And I like my waffle cones crisp and crunchy not soft and chewy.
While I was hoping this place might remind me a bit of Aglamesis (my favorite old school ice cream parlor in Cincinnati), sadly it did not. They do certainly try and they provide service with a simile but they need to work on the quality of their product.