Surprising. Went for Winterlicious. Carpaccio was great. Cacciatore Pizza (they let you choose the type at Winterlicious which is nice) was excellent. Dessert was good. The person I dined with took completely different apps, pizza and desert, which I tasted, and they were all as good as mine. I don't understand how this is only rated at 3.5 stars. One of the best Italian in the city.