The Coronado Cafe seems to be real hit or miss based on the reviews below. I can understand some of the points on the misses, but for me, it was a hit.
PHX seems to be populated with several of these former houses turned restaurants/bars. I'm a fan of their eclecticism. It makes for a fun, intimate setting more often than not. My dinner was tasty and cooked to perfection - no qualms there. But the wait staff was super meh. I'm not a regular at semi-upscale places, but when I am, I certainly shouldn't have to pour my own wine. It just seems declasse. And while we were the last two people in the place on a Thursday night, there was some definite tension in the room to get us to leave. I don't know how long we were there after they technically closed, but it was a tad awkward.
So factoring in my experience with the rest of the reviews, Coronado sounds hit or miss. But if you manage to get the right chef and right waiter combo, it could approach a five star experience. Who doesn't like a little gambling?