We went to this location as it was convenient a few weeks ago. Popeyes in general normally has a small selection on sale (e.g. 8 pieces for $15.99 or whatever) but when we went they did not, so I picked up two orders of a 5 piece dark. I actually didn't know I ordered dark but that is what we ended up with - rib/thigh/drum - THEN I realized it. But this has nothing to do with the rating. The pieces v. price was fair and before I got KFC buckets of dark for $12.99 and that is perfectly fine.
Got it home and it looked like it was sitting for a while - and the breading was darker than normal. Wife said "not fresh/stale/soggy/not good". I said "I agree we won't go back."
Our go to is the one at Yonge and Bernard (doesn't appear to be listed on Yelp). After YEARS of going there, I have never had any issues. Oh well, we tried.