Sorry Mitchell's, I'm a Graeter's girl now. I know that's probably a sin to say in these parts, but I've been there twice in the last few weeks and can't wait to go back again. I've tried orange and cream, vanilla bean, chocolate, and their famous black raspberry chocolate chunk. The orange and cream was my two year son and my favorite...straight up orange creamsicle from childhood vibes. My car obsessed little guy particularly likes sitting at the high top bar facing the street, so he can point out every car.
A couple other things I noticed: price is similar to Mitchell's. You can take pints home, along with candies and gifts. They have a free rewards program. They are happy to hand out samples. And there always seems to be a ton of people working, all very friendly.