Either the previous reviews are a bit off or my tastes are a bit lame (which could very well be true), but I enjoyed the hell out of this place. I stopped in three different nights during a seven day trip to see family in Cleveland Heights and had a good time each night.
Wednesday was the most memorable: I had four PBRs and a Great Lakes porter for about $10. The DJ was crazy. Can't recall his name, but he mixed '90s hip-hop with some of the most ignorant but hilarious trap music. The crowd was cool, friendly even. I was alone and end up hanging out with some young guys and girls afterwards who took me to the Best Steak Gyro in East Cleveland (not recommended, especially since there's one in the Heights that's actually safe, though that location may not serve Colt 45). Overall, cheap drinks, nice folks, and Cleveland's version of the hipster bars you'll find in larger cities--I'll take it.
Just one thing...there's a patio?