This place has the best beer selection in Cleveland. They consistently have the most varied, interesting draft beers around.
Their 4 beer lists - Belgian, Hoppy, House, and Featured vary in price from 4.5 a pint to $9 for 10 oz, depending on the beer's rarity. Their beer sampler ($10 for 4, 4oz samples) is a fun way to try several of the higher alcohol beers without breaking the bank (too much).
Food unfortunately is not nearly as varied or interesting as the beer. I've had pizzas and lamb burgers there, which are good, but never knocked my socks off.
Perhaps the worst thing about the Tap House is how poorly insulated it is. It's a cool old building with exposed brick inside, and an awesome patio for warmer weather but it's rather drafty during Cleveland's many months of chill.