Sarris makes great milk chocolate. You can buy it all around the region, and it's especially prevalent during the holidays. The chocolate covered pretzels are out of this world and many of the meltaways are worth having. I tend toward the peanut butter and cashew.
I've only been to the actual location a few times, but never had a bad experience. It's fun to look around and see the giant chocolate castle. Most recently, I decided to be my own Easter Bunny and have some chocolate shipped to where I live now. 2 day shipping. My only complaint is the use of packaging peanuts. Most companies I order from have moved away from them, so it was a little cringey opening a large box full. Otherwise excellent work all around.