I don't know why Spice gets overlooked when people are considering the best college bars in Oakland. Every time I've been there the night has ended well.
Their drink specials (posted on little menus at the bar and on banners) are hilariously girly but reasonably priced and will knock you on your ass. I had a "Shut Up and Drink" which was a sweet concoction of fruit-flavored rums and mixed fruit juices. I hate to admit to drinking it, but the bartender didn't skimp on the alcohol and yet I could barely taste any. I was randomly singing Lady Gaga's "Poker Face" within 20 minutes, which is always a good sign. They have a nice draft selection and beer specials all the time.
The bartenders are friendly here, unlike the nearby Peter's Pub and PCafe. We went once on a Wednesday night and the bartender taught us how to mix drinks and let us pick the music without paying for the jukebox! We also got a few free drinks. He hit on my friend a bit, but I can't really blame him for that.
This place never seems too packed, even on the busy Karaoke nights. You never have to wait too long for a drink either. I'd much rather spend a night here then wait 30 minutes for a shot at Peter's.
Overall, great service and good prices makes this my favorite college bar in Oakland. Try it instead of PCafe/Peter's/whatever one night, you won't regret it.