Walk past the the Mill Street Brew Pub from the main street, into the Mill Street Store and you will find the Mill Street Beer Hall right across from the entrance. It is a deceptively large space, as it spans all the way to the back and there are plenty of long tables for patrons. It's cosy and inviting during the winter and there is plenty of patio space outside during the summer months.
We came on a Friday night after taking in the LightFest and immediately found a table even though the pub next door was full with a 30 min wait list. The beer menu is extensive and the servers are very helpful in choosing if you get overwhelmed. The smoked brisket burger was good, meat was tender and well seasoned. Fries were demolished also.
Don't get stuck on the wait list for the pub, come here instead!