My opinion of the place has gotten worse and worse each time my family and I visit. This time we happened to stop in at 11:30, which is apparently the end of breakfast time, so we were told that after the last few breakfast plates go out our orders would go in... Mind you, we were HANDED a LUNCH menu. No big deal. We ordered and agreed to wait. Waitress was nowhere to be found, food wasn't far behind. Finally at 12:40 our daughter's Mac and Cheese shows up. The Kraft Mac and Cheese out of the box that I could have gone to the grocery store or even gas station to purchase and make on my own for $1.00, was $5.00. Then I get my fish and chips ten minutes later, which was dripping oil, not at all seasoned, and likely the most bland thing that I've tasted at any restaurant.
We received zero apology or care from our waitress, who disappeared again after our food was brought to us over an hour after ordering. It's very sad because our first visit was really a great one, but I will say now that we will not be returning to the Haymaker.