Atmosphere = A+
Waitstaff = A
Drinks = A
Food = A
Food for the price = Meh
Oliver's is a great place to drink, super friendly staff, good cocktails and awesome vibe. However, I'd only go there to eat again if Tempest, Cento and Tornado were an hour or more wait.
The food is very good but is way too expensive for the end product. If I'm spending close to $100 for two people in Madison, I want a more high-end experience. Totally fair pricing if we were in Chicago, but we aren't.