I stopped by here this past Saturday evening with my wife and 5 other members of my family for dinner. We decided to come here since my sister was in town and Sir Pizza is her favorite pizza place. Normally we would go to the original location (Sewickley Oakmont Rd.) but my mother thought it would be crowded and so we ended up here. The inside of this place looks like many pizza joints as it has a counter to order from up front, a soda machine nearby and then a number of tables and booths to sit at. In addition to this there was a large TV on one of the walls that had sports on it.
For dinner our party decided to order two crusader hoagies and three large pizzas: one plain, one with pepperoni and one half bacon half mushroom. Our pizzas came out rather quickly and I started eating the pepperoni as soon as it hit our table. If you have never been to Sir Pizza before then the first thing that you notice is that they cut their pizzas in an unusual fashion. They cut it three times longways and then three times sideways which gives you a number of different shaped small slices. It can actually be quite nice if you are not looking for a full piece of pizza. One thing that I really enjoy about Sir Pizza is that their pepperoni topping is crumbled pepperoni instead of slices and that it tastes really good. With that being said I really ended up enjoying the pepperoni pizza especially whenever I noticed that the bottom of the crust was crispier than normal. Sadly only the pepperoni was that way and I was slightly disappointed whenever I tried the bacon only to have the crust at the normal crispiness. I ended up not trying the cheese pizza nor the mushroom pizza as the mushrooms looked like canned mushrooms and the cheese was gone by the time we had finished the pepperoni. After the pizzas disappeared I then proceeded to eat most of a crusader hoagie myself. The crusader hoagie consists of ham, salami, capicolla, cheese, onions, lettuce, tomatoes and oil & vinegar all on a 12 inch bun. This particular crusader hoagie seemed to be swimming with the oil & vinegar and while I liked all of the other items in the hoagie, I could have done without most of the dressing.
The bottom line for me is that I am sure I will be back here again in the future. While it is not my favorite pizza in the world, my sister certainly enjoys it and it is nostalgic for me.