I recently used Nedrebo's Formal Wear to rent a tux for a wedding I was in just outside of Madison. Nedrebo's is located in a small strip mall right off Washington Avenue in Madison. While I have not rented a tux since high school prom, at $185.00, the rental price at Nedrebo's seemed a little steep to me. . . oh well I coughed up the money and picked up my tux.
From the moment I walked in, the staff was very welcoming and helpful. I absolutely hate fittings, but the staff was friendly and they helped make the process less dreadful. I had flown into Wisconsin from out of town and had never had an opportunity to try anything on prior to my arrival one day before the wedding. When the jacket seemed a little too large, they quickly called over to another store and had a new jacket delivered that same day within a couple of hours.
Although I do not plan on being in Madison anytime soon, I would not hesitate to recommend Nedrebo's to someone looking to rent a tux. They even throw in the pocket square to keep! While the price seems a little high to me, maybe I am just out of touch with the current going rate for the rental of a tux. The staff is friendly and I was extremely surprised and appreciative at their willingness to quickly get over a new jacket for me on such short notice.