Ok, first off, you can put your name on the waiting list with the yelp app. I was suspect but it works flawlessly! I bookmarked Burgatory for our Pirates game trip and there was no disappointment.
I had an undiscloseable amount of Yuengling on draft and the Piggy Butter & Jelly was the most strangely awesome thing that I have eaten in a long time. No joke, it's wonderful. Candied Bacon, peanut butter, habanero jelly, etc. on a burger, WHAT? So good!
Kids liked the mini burgers and quesadilla. My wife actually had an alcoholic milkshake (I was shocked) was really really good (choco taco milkshake).
A bit higher than most places we go but it was awesome. Local to Pittsburgh with 6 locations and soon to be 7. GO THERE!