I very much enjoyed the play Animal Farm at this venue last Friday evening. They served drinks in the lobby before the show and during intermission and afforded tables where you could actuallt sit and enjoy your beverage.
The theater itself is small enough that every seat will give you a good view of the stage yet large enough accommodate a decent crowd. The seats could be a little more comfortable but that's my only knock on the theater. There's plenty of on-street parking near by and it's located within walking distance of many restaurants for a preshow dinner.
If a show comes to the New Hazlet that catches your interest go ahead and get tickets. You'll most likely have a great time.