Finally used the LivingSocial deal I'd bought for Villa Antonio.
Our table wasn't ready at our reserved time (wound up being seated ~20 minutes late)
Service was okay (_constantly_ refilling of our wine glasses, confusing us with other tables)
Food was okay (we had two different pasta dishes; the tiramisu was very good, huge and rich)
In keeping with "love it or hate it," has to be the latter since we've got better Italian restaurants that are less expensive in the area