I'm surprised the reviews are SO varied...from 1 star to 5 in a matter of days. One of the low stars was a Groupon-er so that prolly explains that one (Groupon-ers are cheap and want the best for the least).
I went on a slow night so there weren't any hipsters and the staff was right there to seat us, get us water etc.
The food was divine. ABSOLUTELY DIVINE. Like 5 star divine. I have recommended it to clients who say it's the only nice restaurant in Liberty Village.
I will try it again and see if all these "bad service" comments have any weight.