I've always been a bit skeptical about this place. For one this used to be an awesome Brazilian restaurant so I was a bit spiteful when it closed. Then throw in that all the 5 star reviews are from people with less than 10 reviews... Like I said, skeptical.
But since moving closer to it, I have stopped in for takeout a couple times and indulged in a few of its offerings, and must say its a damn legit provider of pizza and panzerottis.
The pizza has a nice crust and a wide variety of toppings to choose from. It's not groundbreaking pizza by any means but tasty and they've got a good deal for 2 medium 3 topping pizzas for less than $22 after tax which comes with their house made garlic dipping sauce.
The panzerotti was pretty incredible. You pick 3 toppings for less than $6.50 after tax, and it was one of the best panzerottis I've had in the city. I'll admit that Toronto has a lot of terrible panzerottis to compare to, but this thing was just a good flavour with proper doughiness. While marinara is the traditional sauce of choice for such an item, I'll admit that the garlic sauce was a great replacement.
I'm now convinced of this places legitimacy, and Yummy Pizza gets 4 thumbs up!