I am a fantastic procrastinator so I am finally writing my review of the "Secret Pizza." The concept is fantastic, Italian records on the wall, a pinball machine. Friendly service and cool workers.
So why only 3 stars? It is JUST A-OK. It should have a sign that says" Congratulations you found the hipster Sbarros" That's really all it is, its decent pizza for a decent price (for the strip) and a cool concept. I am rating this on the food not the concept. A Sbarro that you can choose your own toppings is all you get. If you are hammered coming from Marquee then you will probably love this place.
If you are like me and have had good pizza before and are sober when trying it or only a few cocktails in then OK is what you get. . It is the cheapest place to eat in the Cosmo so that probably why people rate it so high.
It is worth checking out or bringing people that have never seen it before but for repeat business it's just not my style.