Oh my! This pizza is addictive. I absolutely love it. There is no pizza in Scottsdale other than Streets of New York that compares. I've got my son hooked on it too. He always asks to make a special trip over to get a few slices.
The eating area is serviceable and fairly clean, with a good view out of the window. Sports usually on TV, which fits. The place is filled with NYC memorabilia from various teams. The woman who runs it seems like a typical no-nonsense New Yorker, so if that's not your style, fa-get-bout-it! Go somewhere else.
The pizza is incredible and it is consistent in its recipe. Very important! And yes, they do stay open late. Some have complained about the different prices from regular hours compared to midnight and beyond. To me, it makes sense. If people want to eat pizza at 2:30 am, be prepared to pay a lot more for it. Its the big-city way. Someones gotta pay for the employees to hang around all night.
In short, get yourself over to Joe's Pizza. Try it plain or Hawaiian style. This is REAL New York Style pizza all the way.