UPDATE:
I received a very friendly message from the owner of Boulders, who apologized for my previous experiences with the food, and offered a free meal with recommendations. Instead of using the free offer from the kind owner, I went back to the restaurant and ordered BOTH of the suggestions that he had: The Asian Bob burger, and the California Carver pizza.
The burger was incredibly juicy and had a nice balance of sweet and savory. Two thumbs up.
The pizza was a crazy amalgamation of all that is yummy: Pepperjack cheese, onion strings, pico de gallo, turkey breast. The serving size was more than adequate for a single person and the taste was great!
Add these two great menu choices with the endless (and ever changing) beer selection, and Boulders on Broadway is a hit!