I have been seeing Dr. Gaishauser since I was a kid, and I still choose to go back even though I don't live in Medina anymore.
Dr. G is extremely personable and makes you feel welcome even as he is digging around in your mouth. He makes you feel like a friend rather than a mouth.
Recently, I returned to the office for the first time in a few years (yay having insurance!), and he remembered what I had been up to and asked about my family. It is this kind of personal touch that will make it hard to move to a new dentist.