I've been a member for almost 5 years now and have absolutely no reason to ever stop paying my annual fee. In fact, I LOVE Fill-A-Seat! And yes... while their website is quite antiquated both visually and functionally, don't let that fool you! The value here is immense! Sign up and you will thank me.
P.S. I would give 5 stars but holding back only a little because their website look, feel and functionality is very dated. The service however (as I mentioned) is tremendous!