if the decor was a bit toned down, or different.. or something, I'd go 5. I loved the old Po Boys, and well... I don't really need to go into a big long deal about how this spot is not like Arnie's spot in Downtown Champaign. I will tell you that they have the original sauce, and the original Polish. I love this combo. The beef, the pork.. about a touch under being great. One thing they have that I f n love, is Chicken, which the Original spot didn't have. I just took stars off from Porgy's for the horrid way they have let their chicken go, but Po Boy's original sauce on that chicken.... It's heaven.